MFlenses - Új élet a digitális korban
MFLenses 2026

Manuális fókuszú objektívek fóruma

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.
Reflektorfény

Kiemelt partneri hely a fórum nyitólapján.

UV Filters?
Előző téma megtekintése :: Következő téma megtekintése  


Reply

The newer filters are being labeled as for use with digital cameras. Are they the same as the older ones that were used on film cameras?

Surely a UV filter is a UV filter?


Reply

I think it is more a marketing trick so that people will buy new filters for their old lens when use on digital camera.


Reply

Actually many UV filters don't even block UV very well; these days they are mostly intended for protection. The “digital” part probably means that the coatings have been applied on the “under” side of the filter as well, to protect against sensor reflections on a digital. Or it could mean a newer coating technology in general. Or it could mean nothing at all.

As for the protective value of these filters, I personally find it rather questionable in most situations, and in some situations having a filter on can actually put the lens in much greater risk of damage than not having a filter on at all… So, I'd suggest only using one of these filters when there's a specific need for it, e.g. when you've got sand or ocean spray flying around or little kids trying to put their fingers into the lens.


Reply

Hi,

martinsmith99 írta:
The newer filters are being labeled as for use with digital cameras. Are they the same as the older ones that were used on film cameras?

Surely a UV filter is a UV filter?


Yes. But if you really want to buy some new ones, i strongly suggest you to get a "well-branded" filter, i.e. B+W MRC, Tiffen, Hoya Pro or, if you can afford them, go for Singh-Ray filters ...

Cheers


Reply

AFAIK, there's only one filter that was produced specifically with digital imaging in mind and that's the clear "Protector".

Ditto to the above post though - if you must use filters, use the best but try and standardise the size as far as possible.


Reply

I never use any filter, apart to get some special features (IR filter, red for BW, sometimes polarizing, or ND1000), I rather use the metal hoods of the Takumar to get a great protection and reduce flare risks (whereas a filter always increase these risks). I tried to use a SMC Pentax A 50/1.7 trough a filter that let pass UV and cut visible light, I only get some violet haze after several seconds of expose, camera pointed to a sunny area, lens at f/1.7...


Reply

I'm much the same with NDs and polarisers etc. and only have filters on my most valuable lenses.


Reply

When I had the Leica M system, I used to do in twice ways.

For Leica: UV Leica filters in all of them (to protect them for resale value)

Others lenses: not filters at all.

Now I not use any filter but lens shade.

Excuse me, but the read of the follow page can be usefull in this theme:

http://www.pentaxforums.com/forums/pentax-slr-lens-discussion/54222-does-uv-filter-helps-cut-down-purple-fringing.html

Rino.


Reply

UV filters are not important for modern lenses: only for lens protection.
POLARIZERS do there job. However each filter will infringe the optical calculation: vignetting, ghost ... I use of course close up lenses http://joergvetter.oyla.de/cgi-bin/hpm_homepage.cgi BR Atomino


Reply

B+W filters perhaps not impact picture quality off brand low cost filters impact pretty well. I use many used UV filters and cheap ones from HK as protection in storage. They are practical transparent lens caps, before I take out my lens to photography I take off UV filters and let them at home.


Reply

I've been using Green.L filters from Ebay, they are very cheap but still multi coated and I can't see any difference with or without them except for when the light source is in or near the frame where there is a 1 or two more discs of flare but I will just take the filter off in these circumstances regardless of how much the filter cost.

I have used some cheap filters that had a very obvious effect on sharpness but these cheap multi coated ones seem to do a pretty good job.

Judging by the group tests I have seen most filters cheap or expensive have little effect on most images until the light source get's near the frame and then it's just a case of how much the filter exaggerates the flare but like I said even with an expensive HD filter I would just unscrew it and put it back on afterwards.

Here's an example of a 67mm Green.L MC UV filter from ebay (cost about £3 delivered)

The lens was a sigma 18-50mm EX DC

Full Scene:



Without Green L:



With Green L:



It's not a totally scientific test as they were taken about 30 minutes apart and the lighting was changeable but I think it gives a pretty good "real world" comparison.


A hozzászólás legutóbb fatdeeman által Hétf. Aug. 09, 2010 9:53 am-kor lett szerkesztve, összesen 1 alkalommal.


Reply

i realize i do not have anywhere near the history with lenses/filters as many of the more talented forum members. but for me i have always agreed with that leica saying 'the glass is everything'. if that is the case, and one pays hundreds, if not thousand?, of dollars on 'the glass', why do you want to put a condom on it? Laughing but seriously, i do enjoy putting special use filters, or effect filters, on from time to time. but if i have great glass, why would i want to shoot through ANOTHER foreign piece of glass? this is a real query, as i never understood the concept.

for protection, i have lens caps. when not practical, i have a lens hood. if i am shooting in horrific conditions of blowing sand etc, maybe a filter, but other than that, i just never understood the theory.


Reply

Interesting arguments here, and it's worth mentioning that the Green L
filters can be purchased from DealExtreme at very low prices.

I have a few, and they seem to be of rather high quality.