MFlenses - Új élet a digitális korban
MFLenses 2026

Manuális fókuszú objektívek fóruma

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.
Reflektorfény

Kiemelt partneri hely a fórum nyitólapján.

Fans (A1 vs QL17)
Előző téma megtekintése :: Következő téma megtekintése  


Reply

Shot with Fuji Superia ISO200 film
Which one is better? And why?

Canon A1 + FD 35-105 Zoom


Canon QL17 GIII


Reply

Hello, Mike.
Taking for granted that the scanning conditions were exactly the same the QL17 looks a bit sharper while the 35-105 fd a tiny bit warmer. These are the facts, then I could do some considerations. What was the lighting conditions, and was the weather windy? The difference in sharpness may lie just here: simply a physical matter. The QL-17 is tinier and lighter and thus simpler to hold firmly at critical speeds (below 1/60") or windy condition, on the other end the 35-105 FD is a big/heavy boy Smile . Then I expect the shutter actuation of the QL17 to be quite light, the mirror recoil of the A1 is not there. What I'm trying to say is that the A1 unsharpness may just be micro motion and not optical matter. All that said my opinion is that they're both fine equipment, each one with its peculiarity and thus better suitable in particular situations rather than others. Regarding the difference in color it looks so minimal that I wouldn't even consider it since it could be easily corrected if needed.

Cheers, M.


Reply

I too think the QL17 is just a touch sharper. But there's also a difference in exposure. At least 1/2 stop, maybe 1 stop, which may account for some of the "warmth" of the A-1 with 35-105 shot and contrast differences. There's also a rather strong magenta cast in both images, but that shouldn't affect contrast or sharpness.

The Canon 35-105 f/3.5 two-ring zoom has long been one of my favorite Canon FD zooms. As sharp as most primes with a relatively fast f/3.5 constant aperture, it's a very useful lens for general photography and even portraits.

And of course, the QL17's lens quality is well known, isn't it. I'd say that it's nice to see the 35-105's performance on par with the QL17's optic.