MFlenses - Új élet a digitális korban
MFLenses 2026

Manuális fókuszú objektívek fóruma

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.
Reflektorfény

Kiemelt partneri hely a fórum nyitólapján.

Canon FD conversions
Előző téma megtekintése :: Következő téma megtekintése  


Reply

Attila írta:
About lens conversion, I am against DIY and crappy conversion at home.
Convert rare lenses quiet painful too as a collector, but acceptable if professionally done.

I support professional conversion what is make perfect product.
If possible reversible conversion is nice.

DIY conversion is a lens butchering in most cases ending badly , just feed curiosity nothing else.

I am enjoy several professionally converted lenses.

If you need to convert a lens ask Trifox first and get a quote , before your butcher a piece of history.


Each lens conversion is a DIY project, also for TRIFOX.. some are crappy, some are good.. depending on individual possibilitys and the possibility given by the lens.

To convert a Canon FD 1.2/85mm in the way Trifox and his guy did, is also "butchery", because this is not reversible.. to a collectors item.
But its a simple and easy way to do that.. take a part of the old mount and bring this to the EF Mount.. but not reversible and under your own conditions, the lens is lost for a collector or analogue photographer.

Sorry, but for me is a rar Lens, which is converted and brought to a new life, used by a photographer in the future more valuable than staying around in a Collectors-cabinett !! or to get fungus in a cellar.

I did a lot of DIY conversions for myself and collegues. Canon FD 1.4/24mm SSC ASPH, FD 1.2/85mm SSC ASPH, Canon FD 1.2/55mm SSC ASPH, Canon FD 1.2/55mm Non ASPH, Canon FD 2/28mm SSC, Canon FD 2/35mm S.S.C., Canon nFD 1.2/50mm, Canon FD 4/80-200mm L, Canon FD 2.8/300mm L and lots of other lenses from Minolta MC and MD 1.7/85mm, MD 2/28mm, MC 1.4/50mm PG and lots more..
dont know exactly how many..

This is not a "butchery".. this is a way to use very good old lenses in modern DSLR-times. Sometimes its possible to make a lens conversion reversible, sometimes not.

But to speak about "butchery".. sorry, but there i have got another opinion...

The history of a lens... its a design element... not more.






Cheers
Henry


Reply

Attila írta:
I have a lens Henry a 12cm Tessar I never seen any other copy ever. Lens was DIY converted wrongly after war I think to get new life on an Exakta body. Conversion was done badly , lens has museum value now which is highly degraded due bad conversion.
Around century people in Egypt put into fire mumies ,because they found plenty of them. Lens conversion pretty much last solution to me to save a lens life, especially today when we have plenty of choices to mount any lenses on digital bodies. A professionally finished lens conversion is more acceptable to me than a functional but really bad looking one.


Hi Attila,

yes, under this circumstance (if a lens is really rar), you are right, but most of the conversions today are done with lenses, you can more or less easily find again on eBay..

Canon or Minolta lenses are "mass products" from older days.. only usable on 4/3 cam or other crops like NEX (showing only the half of the truth) ... but this lenses are fabulous on modern DSLR like the EOS 5D.. why not convert to EOS?

The lens quality is as good as lenses from today.. handling and haptical better..

Butchery means only bad conversion without love for the lens itself..in my opinion.

I think its a better way to show the people, how they do a good conversion.. by showing them tools, instructions and solutions from lots of people. This will make the conversions better..

Cheers
Henry


Reply

ZoneV írta:
Attila írta:
...
I support professional conversion what is make perfect product.
If possible reversible conversion is nice.
....


What is professional?

My DIY home conversion of the Canon FD 85/1.2L seems to be the first (published) full reversible mount conversion of this fine - but not extremly rare - lens.
Professional conversion stores convert this lens - as far as I know - not reversible.
So that seems to me, that home conversion could be sometimes (!) better for rare lenses - because DIY converters do it for curiosity, and so time for a harder reversible conversion is not that problem.


Zonev - if you do conversion for customer -- you want to make it fully functional and the lens is expected to be fully maintained

that means -- any customer or anyone else needs to take the lens in bits easily and re-assemble again.

and -- the lens is expected to be ---- looking nice -- it's sounds ridiculous but -- it's important.

If you think that the rear mount -- see the part on the left is OK and you do this for customer -- than I am not sure about those holes ..

it looks very bad to be honest..

if you think that you can deliver that to someone else -- than god safe you!



tf


Reply

hinnerker írta:
Attila írta:
About lens conversion, I am against DIY and crappy conversion at home.
Convert rare lenses quiet painful too as a collector, but acceptable if professionally done.

I support professional conversion what is make perfect product.
If possible reversible conversion is nice.

DIY conversion is a lens butchering in most cases ending badly , just feed curiosity nothing else.

I am enjoy several professionally converted lenses.

If you need to convert a lens ask Trifox first and get a quote , before your butcher a piece of history.


Each lens conversion is a DIY project, also for TRIFOX.. some are crappy, some are good.. depending on individual possibilitys and the possibility given by the lens.

To convert a Canon FD 1.2/85mm in the way Trifox and his guy did, is also "butchery", because this is not reversible.. to a collectors item.
But its a simple and easy way to do that.. take a part of the old mount and bring this to the EF Mount.. but not reversible and under your own conditions, the lens is lost for a collector or analogue photographer.

Sorry, but for me is a rar Lens, which is converted and brought to a new life, used by a photographer in the future more valuable than staying around in a Collectors-cabinett !! or to get fungus in a cellar.

I did a lot of DIY conversions for myself and collegues. Canon FD 1.4/24mm SSC ASPH, FD 1.2/85mm SSC ASPH, Canon FD 1.2/55mm SSC ASPH, Canon FD 1.2/55mm Non ASPH, Canon FD 2/28mm SSC, Canon FD 2/35mm S.S.C., Canon nFD 1.2/50mm, Canon FD 4/80-200mm L, Canon FD 2.8/300mm L and lots of other lenses from Minolta MC and MD 1.7/85mm, MD 2/28mm, MC 1.4/50mm PG and lots more..
dont know exactly how many..

This is not a "butchery".. this is a way to use very good old lenses in modern DSLR-times. Sometimes its possible to make a lens conversion reversible, sometimes not.

But to speak about "butchery".. sorry, but there i have got another opinion...

The history of a lens... its a design element... not more.






Cheers
Henry

]

Henry first of all -- I am not doing butchery -- and please, be informed that 'my guy' has been sent to hell for ever...

I am using lathe and proper machines and not dremel !!

If I want to make a ring with 100 per cent accuracy which fits into EF mount -- I can assure you that the ring is going to fit into the mount in 100 per cent - with no 'light' around..

and this is your sample -- you've mentioned I do butchery is -- ouch!



You did that ring from plastic - I am able to make my own with more accuracy - and I show you that..

oh! Kiron 105 f2.8 macro -- how would you do the aperture mechanism? - the tube is long like hell and the aperture lever needs to be under constant tension for all focal distances?

any thoughts?

tf


Reply

but back to the Attila's problem

That is serious damage and loss!!!

The main problem with conversion is - we need to know how the lens is alike.

how it works -- how it focuses and bla bla .. how it has been built!

The conversion is --- 5 times think and only once cut! IF any cut needs to be done --- glass must go out of the barrel!!

How can someone start drilling the mount with the glass?


Reply

who made it just was an average as*hole who got this lens cheaply I think . How many times I did hear I not pay for pro work like yours, because more expensive the lens itself. Perhaps same people not buy a lens with a small scratch Laughing


Reply

@TRIFOX

First of all, what you showing, is a prototype of my own lens from where i start doing conversions... !!!

You will not really say, that you havent done "prototype" work if you see a lens the first time...oh no, dont say that ?

Today the conversions are done this way..

Canon 1.2/85mm SSC ASPH.. adjustment of rear lens state 1&2.




and a special machined thread on a professional machine..



And the 2. version of the 1.2/55mm SSC..



Or do you prefer this outfit with a M42 black and a Chromring?



Or the Canon FD 1.2/55mm Aspherical? From the rear side?



But i am not interested in a competition of "who is doing a cosmetical better looking conversion.. for me its more interesting, that the things are working perfect..

So i use a lot of good tools for measuring to get precise results for the 1.2/85mm ASPh and the 1.2/55mm ASPH...





I think you did understand my post wrong.. butchery means.. not reversible.. not that you a butcher !!

But iam looking forward to see some of your work in details..

Cheers
Henry


Reply

Henry -- I fully agree with you!

-- I am trying to get fully functional result and

I am always black Smile ! I simply do not like chrome mount as the black looks better

another thing is -- your holes are still very close to the middle!

Another thing is -- and I show you what -- how would you fill the gap between the rear glass and mount? Smile

I am just asking!

But you must admit that your previous statement -- ' i have done conversion of 55 f1.2 and it's easy! is not true Wink hey?

No -- simply is not easy!

BTW -- why do you make a thread in to the mount? Wink

I am just curious!!

tf


Reply

Henry

I do not why - but both Robert and I, we found all these conversions on internet as a waste of time

I have never done any prototype of my conversion Smile...

Never!! I am so sorry to say that - but all is in my head... and hands

Believe or not my imagination is very good -- I do not have to do prototype to get what I want

The trick is -- you must think -- and get through all combinations possible -- believe or not -- from some point, I'll get it..

No prototype - it;s me and my strong will to win over technical problem .. Smile impossible? no!

I have started using new material - as additional -- just today. as you can not do all from metal - you need to do something from plastic..

What would you recommend to use for filling the gap between the mount and rear glass?

Thanks

S


Reply

trifox írta:
...............
oh! Kiron 105 f2.8 macro -- how would you do the aperture mechanism? - the tube is long like hell and the aperture lever needs to be under constant tension for all focal distances?

any thoughts?

tf


Yes..

Which mount? FD?

Most of the times a push/pull mechanic works..

like in the FD 1.2/55mm...



I use a spring to pull the aperture.. and the internal block near the fork plays the push part.

If you have a long extension tube, for example the Tokina AT-X M90 Makro, i realize that on the aperture ring itself.. with a small workaround..



So the long lever can be assembled on this bridge..

Cheers
Henry


Reply

Ok - henry -- that's is enough

Simply -- not - your spring version doesn't work for me ...

I have a feeling that all is now turning into 'clash' of neurons Smile ( I am trying to make a joke!, of course)

but I will show you how to send that spring to hell Smile

S


Reply

I mean the spring on the Kiron Macro 105 f2.8 of course!

I must go to sleep now but really looking for tomorrow..

night night!

tf


Reply

trifox írta:
Henry -- I fully agree with you!

-- I am trying to get fully functional result and

I am always black Smile ! I simply do not like chrome mount as the black looks better

another thing is -- your holes are still very close to the middle!

Another thing is -- and I show you what -- how would you fill the gap between the rear glass and mount? Smile

I am just asking!

But you must admit that your previous statement -- ' i have done conversion of 55 f1.2 and it's easy! is not true Wink hey?

No -- simply is not easy!

BTW -- why do you make a thread in to the mount? Wink

I am just curious!!

tf


Hi Stan,

i did make the thread in the mount for exactly positioning/adjust the rear element either to infinity or to closer distances to let the mirror of a 5D passing the rear lens without hitting her.

If you mean the gap near the contact panel of the EOS system, i am working on a complete revision of this way.. so i machine a new mounting for the rear lens... and use another Adaptor in the second stage.

The next stage would not longer need the old FD Part for holding the rear element.. a totally new adjustable mount will will take place in the middle of a simple M42 adaptor.

I will show the result, if this adaptor and the new part is complete.

Cheers
Henry


Reply

hinnerker írta:


Hi Stan,

i did make the thread in the mount for exactly positioning/adjust the rear element either to infinity or to closer distances to let the mirror of a 5D passing the rear lens without hitting her.

Cheers
Henry



I am still here
Henry - another question - so infinity - yes or no?

If you move the rear glass to the film plane - infinity yes - but the mirror clashes on 5D

if you move the rear glass towards to the lens - mirror is ok - but you can loose infinity..

tf


Reply

trifox írta:
hinnerker írta:


Hi Stan,

i did make the thread in the mount for exactly positioning/adjust the rear element either to infinity or to closer distances to let the mirror of a 5D passing the rear lens without hitting her.

Cheers
Henry



I am still here
Henry - another question - so infinity - yes or no?

If you move the rear glass to the film plane - infinity yes - but the mirror clashes on 5D

if you move the rear glass towards to the lens - mirror is ok - but you can loose infinity..

tf


Infinity?

Possibly yes in a later stage/state of developement,

but not on a 5D at the moment state.. maybe with the new machined part i developed. Have to wait some weeks for the first "prototype".

At the moment the mirror clashes near 15 meters. Thats exactly the reason, why i develope the new (dont know the english expression for the part, who holds the rear lens in place) part.

I am optimistical about that, because then the vertex of the lens would be the only limiting factor and not the old part of the FD Mount on which the mirror hangs in the upper 1/3 section of the mirror-housing.....

The owner of the 1.2/85mm did know the problem and decided for itself, to use the lens at infinity on a EOS 7 D instead of his 5D MKII with limited focus distance for cinema-work. Maybe in a later state of the conversion with the new "holder" of the rear lens, we change that mount again with the new machined one. But this all depends on further developments.. otherwise he will later on shave the mirror of the 5D MKII

Back to your question about infinity or not..

You can adjust nearly each position of the moving optical part in relation of the rear lens relatively with the infinity limiter..



Let us see, what happens with the new part for the rear lens.

This holds the rear lens in an own (only in german = Fassung/Einfassung"Mounting?) and would look like that..

(this is a scheme !! not the real new part!)



On the left, this is the new "scheme".. adjustable with a smaller rear-lens housing as the old FD part on the right.

Therefore a new part will machined... so the angular point of the lens and the new mount are closer together in the center and not limited by the old FD housing. You win about 0.3-0.4mm for infinity and the mirror problem.. maybe more after adjusting.

The back of the old FD part stands 1.6mm - 1.8mm over the adaptor (depending on where the infinity limiter position stands) and the mirror clashes, but on other lenses with better angular/vertex, like the 1.4/24mm the rear lens can stand 2.24mm over the adaptor without mirror problems....





And this is the back of the 1.2/85mm SSC at this old state .. nice with the chromring isnt it?



And a last answer to your question about the thread in the adaptor showing some posts before..



as you can see with such a machined thread its possible to
1. adjust the rear lens and
2. also to transplant the ball bearings together with the lever of the old FD Mount mechanic.. (realized with a T2 to EOS adaptor)

But this nice and interesting discussion is really out of topic... we can discuss some aspects also on PM..

Have a nice day..

Cheers
Henry


Reply

Good morning Henry -- I do also not go ahead with in this discussion and I would start a new topic in REPAIRS.. if you don't mind

tf


Reply

I have split this topic as the discussion went in different direction..

tf


Reply

At first: I do not claim to make perfect or professional mount conversions.
And I do not doubt trifox`s conversion quality.
I do only claim that one could make good enough reversible mount conversions without having a conversion business.

trifox írta:
...
Zonev - if you do conversion for customer -- you want to make it fully functional and the lens is expected to be fully maintained

that means -- any customer or anyone else needs to take the lens in bits easily and re-assemble again.
...


Yes, I try to make the lens serviceable for others - the FD500/4.5L and FD300/2.8L are bad in this regard. The newer conversions of the 400/2.8L and 85/1.2L are better - the 85/1.2L is not full ready yet.

At the moment I try to make the nFd mount conversions fully reversible. There is no Canon part modified or alterd. No holes, no grinding.
So I could take my nFd 85/1.2L with EF mount apart, and make it to nFD again - with its own parts.

trifox írta:
...
and -- the lens is expected to be ---- looking nice -- it's sounds ridiculous but -- it's important.
...


For me that is not a problem. I do conversions for my own, and if someone is supid enough to ask me to convert a lens, he see on my website what I do - and what not.
And I tell him that there is the risk of a full disaster, because I am not a trained camera repairman.

trifox írta:
...
If you think that the rear mount -- see the part on the left is OK and you do this for customer -- than I am not sure about those holes ..

it looks very bad to be honest..


Whats wrong about those holes? Sure, they are not absolutly perfect - but I think that could not be seen on this image Smile
I copy the hole position from the FD part. There is some tolerance in this copying :-/

I take the original FD holes, beacause with those holes I do not need drilling new ones (what would harm my concept of 100% reversibility).
With these original holes the lens worked for ages, so I do not think I need new hole positions.
The converted nFd 400/2.8L could be hanged on a camera with its 5 kg - with the original holes. I could hold my own converted nFD300/2.8L horizontal - with only holding the camera. I tested that, because Henry not beliefs in the the original new FD mount stability - and others doubt the mount stability of normal Canon EF lenses.

About machinery:
trifox írta:
...I am using lathe and proper machines and not dremel !!
...

I use a Rotwerk mini lathe and a small Proxxon mill with dividing attachment. I get small tolerances with that. The backlens of the FD 85/1.2 was holding in my drilled ring - without glue or screw, only thight fit.

trifox írta:
... The main problem with conversion is - we need to know how the lens is alike.

how it works -- how it focuses and bla bla .. how it has been built!

The conversion is --- 5 times think and only once cut! IF any cut needs to be done --- glass must go out of the barrel!!
...


Yes, I agree.
I work as an ~ optics engineer (not lens designer) at a camera company and my professional background helps me to understand problems and to solve them. Furthermore I have 5 years of mechanical lessons in school - long ago.

I do not have your imagination and mechanical skill, and therefore need prototyps of my own made parts. But with the nFd lenses I could do this without harming the lens - need only time to manufacture this parts.
What I have - and what I like - is the ability to make small innovations. I do not have the target to get things looking perfect. If they work for me its ok - I like to use the photo gear.


Reply

ZoneV - I am not perfect too -- I also must do too much with my hands and brain.

It's a brain which brings all together...

ZoneV - your Proxxon is more than perfect machine!!! Proxxon is not really cheapo machine..
-- if you have such a perfect tool -- - you have all in your hands!

I am not taking any criticism over all --!

So - back to the holes - if you like them I do not care .... it's your problem...

ZoneV - with your tools, the lens must be like for exhibition! Wink but if your prefer to do the conversion fully reversible -

hat off! and I am not writing anything..

Do not get me wrong and please, do not take it personally --

I wouldn't like to harm anyone here.. !

tf


Reply

and also --

I am respecting you and Henry.

I just didn't like Henry's statement - trifox and he's guy do 'butchery' Smile ouch!

But Henry made it clear that was misunderstanding.

so all is ok now - I will be back with the Kiron macro. Smile

just for our further discussion .. Smile

tf


Reply

trifox írta:
...
ZoneV - with your tools, the lens must be like for exhibition! Wink but if your prefer to do the conversion fully reversible -

hat off! and I am not writing anything..
..


Oh not!
Please write further!
I would wish to have your brain regarding the mechanics - I need everytime my hand on the lens, and test what is best.

As I see your reaction I suppose my last post was to hard - I am not good at English writing.

You drill the holes further on the outside to have smaller forces on the screws? And easier drilling I suppose - those original hole positions are not easy to drill in a more or less good looking manner.

I have the cheapest Proxxon MF 70 - and the Rotwerk was a real bargain (with some risk whilst buying).


Reply

Ok - so let's go ahead Wink

This is just a one little detail as I have been not happy about the gap between rear elements and mount

and it's time to solve the problem for ever! Smile

First of all -- a little 'butchery' and literally !! Smile

Step one - piece of PLASTIC - yes! it's necessary -- the metal is simply not enough Wink


Step - let's cut the 'BLACK SALAMI' Smile it's very special but doesn't taste good!


Step three - just cut off a smaller piece - still enough for too small lenses


Step four - turning


Step five - turning and it's ready for next cut..


it looks like a PIRRELLI tyre for F1? or not?

next pics - soon..

tf


Reply

My favourite tool is the Dremel 4000 in addition with the Dremel workstation. Its the best Dremel you could buy. If i need special parts for a conversion, i have got the possibility to use a CNC lathe in a company near my home. A good friend gives me the possibility to develop and realize special parts on their machines. They produce fine mechanical parts for medical industrie.

After finding a good way to bring the adaptors on their industriell CNC machines, there is no problem if i need special parts. The only thing.. i have to wait, because all production capacities are busy for some weeks.

But to wait sometimes is an advantage on the other hand. There are new ideas, which can realize and they are willing to modify the CAD scheme for me..

For example..

This was a simple M42 adaptor..




The brought the adaptor to an inner diameter of 48mm.. and chase a new thread in it, for what? (this is the "butchery - Part" of the conversion..



But after that "butchery"... and some sanding for correct heights, it come to the new mount .. (picture is showing the old FD part without the rear glas element)...



Now the lens is adjustable in height.. (its a Canon FD 1.2/85mm Asperical conversion)..

After the first part of the conversion, the new mount can be used for the following..

This is the inner part of the old FD Mount.. 2 parts are screwed together..





Why?
Because we want to bring the old lever and the ballbearing to the new mount !





Therefore we need the locking ring.. seen next picture.. its the same ring, we use for adjusting the rear lens in height.. !! Only a second one for the job..



And at the end it looks like that..




This is, what the next stage of conversion adaptors will give me..

sorry, but all this i cant do it in my brain without trying some things.. as hard as i try it.

This is development in stages..

Cheers
Henry


Reply

ok - next set..

The ring is finished on lathe Smile -- and believe or not - its fits between the rear group and the adapter --

this is customer lens and he wants AF-EMF chip - I recommend him to get a cheap one from China ...

There is no glue or screw -- the good thing is that the plastic part fits perfectly but it doesn't move -- and the rear group just sliding on the surface of the inner tube - amazing material..









tf


Reply

trifox írta:
.....
it looks like a PIRRELLI tyre for F1? or not?

next pics - soon..

tf


Yes, Pirelli tyre for my slotcars.. Very Happy

Thanks for sharing this..

Cheers
Henry