MFlenses - Új élet a digitális korban
MFLenses 2026

Manuális fókuszú objektívek fóruma

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.
Reflektorfény

Kiemelt partneri hely a fórum nyitólapján.

On filter ring dents
Előző téma megtekintése :: Következő téma megtekintése  


Reply

I have a few thoughts on filter ring dents. First, they are a pestilence. I brought in a nice Hexanon 40mm f1.8 yesterday which has a dented filter ring. I knew about the dent at time of purchase, of course. But such dents are annoying.

eBay certainly has answers to this dilemma. Our Chinese friends, for example, are always eager to help us out:

Kattints ide az eBay-en való megtekintéshez

Do bring lots of money.

And here is another tool which costs less. I like it more:

Kattints ide az eBay-en való megtekintéshez

Not to diminish or demean the above, but I'm a believer in the old addage: "Free is cheap"

With the caveat I have access to a lathe (two, actually; a smaller Hardinge cataract lathe and a larger South Bend), and acknowledging that might constitute unfair advantage, I'm thinking in terms of a tool best described perhaps as a cone section. Made of wood, or maybe of plastic pipe, something softer than aluminum anyway, it would be lathe turned to a very gradual taper. After disassembling the lens you would insert the small end of the cone into the (dented) filter ring and force the ring up the cone, thereby removing the dent.

I realize the eBay solutions do not require lens disassembly. But often dented lenses need to be refurbished anyway. My Hexanon 40mm, for example, needs to be re-greased and the front element needs to be cleaned. And I'm not certain I'd be comfortable using either of those tools from eBay to remove a filter ring dent, working only millimeters away from a front lens element. One slip and it could be "good-bye lens"!!

So how do you fellows repair dented filter rings?


Reply

Well, my old repairman simply used a suitable round hardwood block (or would make one)
and a small wooden hammer or wood block, would fit the former into the lens front and use
the latter to tap on the bent front ring while turning the lens back and forth until the dent is
gone. I do the same and it works pretty well (if not bent too much and no crack) - at no cost Wink


Reply

My home made repair jig is made from some scrap ABS plastic, the two main parts are held together with self tapping screws. The punch is also ABS, and is soft enough that it doesn't damage the filter threads, unless you hit it too hard. I sometimes run some electrical insulating tape over the end of the punch as well, that helps to keep the thread undamaged. There is tape around the rim of the cradle which helps to stop damage to the paint.


The cradle is about 58mm dia, the Tamron is a nice fit, but I repair smaller diameter lenses with this, I modify the radius of the punch with a file to suit smaller diameter lenses. Obviously for larger diameters I would need to make another cradle.
There is some foam rubber to support the lens, I just add a bit or take it away as needed. Having support at the back allows me to use the punch in one hand and the hammer in the other. I use a small hammer, lightly - don't try to straighten a lens ring all in one stroke with a big lump hammer!






I've had good results from this contraption, I did a Tokina AF zoom lens that had been dropped a few weeks ago for someone and got a filter to screw in easily. If suitable plastic isn't available then wood will be just as good.

I made this in a hurry to do a lens and was going to make a better job with different diameter cradles that slotted in to a base, and them make an adjustable support. But I didn't need to, this works just fine.


Reply

guardian írta:
I realize the eBay solutions do not require lens disassembly. But often dented lenses need to be refurbished anyway. My Hexanon 40mm, for example, needs to be re-greased and the front element needs to be cleaned. And I'm not certain I'd be comfortable using either of those tools from eBay to remove a filter ring dent, working only millimeters away from a front lens element. One slip and it could be "good-bye lens"!!

The problem I've found too often is that the dented ring prevents the engraved ring from being unscrewed, so it's impossible
to get to the screws which mount the filter ring on the lens. If you can get the ring off then your cone seems a great idea, but
all too often it has to be repaired while still mounted on the lens body.


Reply

peterqd írta:
guardian írta:
I realize the eBay solutions do not require lens disassembly. But often dented lenses need to be refurbished anyway. My Hexanon 40mm, for example, needs to be re-greased and the front element needs to be cleaned. And I'm not certain I'd be comfortable using either of those tools from eBay to remove a filter ring dent, working only millimeters away from a front lens element. One slip and it could be "good-bye lens"!!

The problem I've found too often is that the dented ring prevents the engraved ring from being unscrewed, so it's impossible
to get to the screws which mount the filter ring on the lens. If you can get the ring off then your cone seems a great idea, but
all too often it has to be repaired while still mounted on the lens body.



This is superb thinking and I thank you for your post. I defer to your thought process here. I didn't think of that . . . but I should have!!

Oh, well. Back to the drawing board! Another "great idea" bites the dust. Laughing