MFlenses - Új élet a digitális korban
MFLenses 2026

Manuális fókuszú objektívek fóruma

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.

Fedezd fel a régi objektívek világát javítási jegyzetekkel, valódi tesztképekkel és képekkel teli archív témákkal.
Reflektorfény

Kiemelt partneri hely a fórum nyitólapján.

Selecting for 'The Look'
Előző téma megtekintése :: Következő téma megtekintése  


Reply

Converting this sample picture today, I was reminded - as I often am with this lens - why it's still worthwhile to use enlarger lenses compared to modern taking lenses. They're cheap, and there's the novelty effect, and it's gratifying to wander off the beaten track. But more than that - enduringly - they have a potently appealing drawing style, reminiscent to me of classic cine lenses. Indeed, they are often closely related.

I'm still mentally wrong-footed every time I view an image like the common-or-garden shot below, in today's mizzly overcast light - not memorable or noteworthy as an image in its own right, but typical of a particular look. At any scale, you're struck by the low contrast - even after minor correction. We've been conditioned to view higher and higher contrast as a metric of better and better performance - feel those whiter whites! And yet - especially with the accessibility of near-lossless tonal adjustment in post - a low-contrast capture is often more desirable, and flexible - hence V-LOG.

Gracefully-sloped highlight and shadow transitions tend to be associated with larger formats and greater dynamic range, and that's a good thing. Sometimes high-contrast optics are a liability. Low-contrast footage, or stills, can always be revved up in post but modern lenses are often difficult - sometimes impossible - to restrain from clipping highlights and filling in shadows, especially when using small sensors. Micro 4/3 is still has major, fundamentally baked-in problems in this area. Enlarger (and cine) lenses are a solution.

So we see 'low contrast' and we immediately look for vignetting, chromatic aberration and soft corners: as photographers we're accustomed to those properties being indivisible - reminding us of the presence of a vintage lens - look at me! I'm old!. And yet, there's no vignetting or aberration. Despite the low contrast, there's consistently high resolution from corner to corner. I find this look extremely 'relaxing': subtle, nuanced and natural - even poetic. The imaging chain just gets out of the way and lets the subject speak.

What lenses do you use for 'the look'? And how would you articulate or demonstrate it?



Perfex 75mm f3.5 at f3.5


A hozzászólás legutóbb 16:9 által Csüt. Jún. 09, 2022 4:01 pm-kor lett szerkesztve, összesen 1 alkalommal.


Reply

I am not sure if I really select for "the look", but I think know what you are saying. My Steinheil 200mm 4.5 that has a certain look to it that is perhaps somewhat similar to your very nice picture, although that does suffer from many of the problems you mention. I find it difficult to articulate what I am seeing, but I suspect you are right when you say it is related to contrast.

Aside, how do you adapt an enlarger lens? I assume there are no standard solutions here?

Regards, C.


Reply

Let us grapple with the ineffable, and see if we may not eff it after all. [slightly misquoting Douglas Adams].

Enlarger lenses are easy to adapt - especially if they come in an M39 mount: M39/M42 step rings are commonly available, as are M42 > Camera Body adaptors and M42 (and other) focusing helicoids. I'm preparing a (very short) article about lens adaptation in general, but there isn't much to say in this chapter: you just
1. screw the step-ring onto the lens
2. screw the lens onto the helicoid
3. screw the helicoid into the adaptor and
4. mount it on whichever camera you're using this week.

If you change camera, you just change the mount adaptor. For a more versatile system that covers projector and enlarger lenses that aren't as easily adaptable to M42, see VNEX.

Many enlarger lenses cover larger formats, and/or have large enough image circles to permit tilt and/or shift movements on 35mm and smaller sensors.


Reply

Indeed, there are a couple of lenses I'd like to go back to more often because of the way the images tend to look...

One of the recent one is the Noritsu 38-60 mm f/4-4.8 minilab lens:

Newlywets by simple.joy, on Flickr

All light is born in stars by simple.joy, on Flickr

Make light of heavy water by simple.joy, on Flickr

I just love the combination of sharpness and soft transitions. It's often available for around 20-30$, however it's not that easy to adapt, so probably not interesting for many.

The Agfa Colostar lenses also come to mind... not the sharpest or best lenses around, but many seem to have a wonderful well-rounded look in my eyes. Your Perfex lens is another great example. It might not be the perfect choice for all occasions but in the example it works exceptionally well!


Reply

Nice shot! I too, love the look of the enlarger lenses. I am quite fond of the ridiculously sharp and apochromatically corrected apo-rodagons, apo componon and EL Nikkors and have a collection of each. But some of the ridiculously cheap midrange lenses from various companies pergorm quite well. I bought a group of 7 lenses for like 10 dollars and amongst them was a


Reply

Just waiting for Gerald to come along and tell you how stupid you are for wasting your time with inferior lenses. Wink

But I'll encourage you to keep going, I like enlarger lenses and among my favourites are th 9cm Ross Resolux (tessar type with buckets of character, the 4 inch Kodak Ektar (4/4 dialyte, very sharp) and the Rodenstock APO Rodagon-D 75mm (double gauss, just superb in all aspects).


Reply

Yes, we are all wasting our time. No photographer should take any photo unless they are using a Hasselblad or Phase One...


Reply

simple.joy írta:
Indeed, there are a couple of lenses I'd like to go back to more often because of the way the images tend to look...

One of the recent one is the Noritsu 38-60 mm f/4-4.8 minilab lens:


I can see why you like that. These images look great.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 írta:

But I'll encourage you to keep going, I like enlarger lenses and among my favourites are th 9cm Ross Resolux (tessar type with buckets of character, the 4 inch Kodak Ektar (4/4 dialyte, very sharp) and the Rodenstock APO Rodagon-D 75mm (double gauss, just superb in all aspects).


That's great. I have the Resolux 9 cm as well but not used it yet. It's a great looking lens though - I appreciate the simplicity. Do you have any example that shows what you mean by its character? I wasn't aware one of the Kodak Enlarging Ektar lenses is a dialyte... As far as ELs go I'm only aware of the Meyer Helioplan series, many of the other lenses with that design seem to have been made for repro work. Opinions on the APO Rodagon-D vary a lot... some think it's one of the most overrated lenses of all time, others (like me) really like it. I'm using the 2X version though - don't have any experience with the one you have.


caspert79 írta:
simple.joy írta:
Indeed, there are a couple of lenses I'd like to go back to more often because of the way the images tend to look...

One of the recent one is the Noritsu 38-60 mm f/4-4.8 minilab lens:


I can see why you like that. These images look great.


Thank you very much - I'm glad you think so!

It's completely subjective of course, but this lens and its way of rendering the background, was a real inspiration for me. It may not look like much, but it changed my approach and idea for the following image, which sparked a series of similar experiments:

You're a light collector as well? by simple.joy, on Flickr

This - among other things - makes me use a lens like that more often than an optically superior modern lens, which is why I chose it as an example. There are many more though and I have a handful of lenses in a backlog, which I can't wait to try again as soon as a situation or idea comes up, which I can imagine being just the thing to unlock their full potential.

Diagnosis: loss of trust in medicine... by simple.joy, on Flickr


Reply

Those are beautiful images that display a lot of artistic and aesthetic quality.

So much for all this obnoxious dogma about how we should concern ourselves with the technical qualities of vintage lenses otherwise we are stupid. That's a neofascist viewpoint from minds that aren't remotely capable of the sort of artistic expression of others with more open mindsets as to what tools they use.

I'm currently really enjoying using an old Tessar 2.8/23 I ripped out of a broken Rollei A110 and remounted to use on my M4/3 cameras. It has this tonality that I find beautiful and most unlike what a more modern, technically 'better' lens would produce. Yes, it's due to a combination of lower contrast and uncorrected aberrations, mostly a slight diffuse glow caused by spherical aberration, which means this is a rather flawed lens compared to what is the state of the art today, but I love it and enjoy using it, which is what counts.

#1


#2


#3


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 írta:
So much for all this obnoxious dogma about how we should concern ourselves with the technical qualities of vintage lenses otherwise we are stupid. That's a neofascist viewpoint from minds that aren't remotely capable of the sort of artistic expression of others with more open mindsets as to what tools they use.


Fortunately I don't hear that viewpoint too often.

A lens is the tone of voice your images speak in. If your photography isn't saying anything you're just mucking about.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 írta:
Those are beautiful images that display a lot of artistic and aesthetic quality.

#3


Thank you very much!

That shot is really fantastic - it has a very unique look and perspective. Works exceptionally well! There are some wonderful Tessars really, not only from Zeiss but also some of the SK Xenars as well as the incredible (Reverse Tessar) Taylor Hobson Ental II series for example.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 írta:
Those are beautiful images that display a lot of artistic and aesthetic quality.

So much for all this obnoxious dogma about how we should concern ourselves with the technical qualities of vintage lenses otherwise we are stupid. That's a neofascist viewpoint from minds that aren't remotely capable of the sort of artistic expression of others with more open mindsets as to what tools they use.


My friend, if you want to keep your sanity it is best to just ignore it rather than get wound up over it. Unfortunately society is (and always has been) full of examples like this, not only relating to art, and increasingly so since the advent of social media. If you have ever tried to argue with anyone (esp. on-line) who claims some music/band is objectively "bad", clearly based on the fact they simply don't like it, you'll know what I mean.

I personally draw the line when inappropriate use of tools, or use of poor tools is doing actual damage that affects others or is either a nuisance or poses a danger to others, at which point stating a strong opinion or warning becomes meaningful. Outside of that, use whatever tools you want however you want to and don't be annoyed or discouraged by advice that conflicts with your own objectives and/or experience...


Reply

simple.joy,

Those are some really striking images! Like 1 small


Reply

RokkorDoctor írta:
iangreenhalgh1 írta:
Those are beautiful images that display a lot of artistic and aesthetic quality.

So much for all this obnoxious dogma about how we should concern ourselves with the technical qualities of vintage lenses otherwise we are stupid. That's a neofascist viewpoint from minds that aren't remotely capable of the sort of artistic expression of others with more open mindsets as to what tools they use.


My friend, if you want to keep your sanity it is best to just ignore it rather than get wound up over it. Unfortunately society is (and always has been) full of examples like this, not only relating to art, and increasingly so since the advent of social media. If you have ever tried to argue with anyone (esp. on-line) who claims some music/band is objectively "bad", clearly based on the fact they simply don't like it, you'll know what I mean.

I personally draw the line when inappropriate use of tools, or use of poor tools is doing actual damage that affects others or is either a nuisance or poses a danger to others, at which point stating a strong opinion or warning becomes meaningful. Outside of that, use whatever tools you want however you want to and don't be annoyed or discouraged by advice that conflicts with your own objectives and/or experience...


Wise words Mark. For me, a large part of my enjoyment of the hobby is in the tinkering around with the most unusual and esoteric optics, sometimes it produces worthwhile results, sometimes not, it's all about the pleasure of the process, the mucking about in the best British 'man in his shed' tradition.


Reply

simple.joy írta:
That shot is really fantastic - it has a very unique look and perspective. Works exceptionally well! There are some wonderful Tessars really, not only from Zeiss but also some of the SK Xenars as well as the incredible (Reverse Tessar) Taylor Hobson Ental II series for example.


Cheers. I have a thing for shadows and have tried a few times to get a nice shot of that tree's shadow against the end wall of that house - it's right opposite my front door so I see it all the time.

I agree on the Tessar, one of my favourites is a Ross Xpress 4 inch that seems to be very rare as I have never been able to find any info on it or a similar example.


Reply

Please don't think I'm anti-'mucking about' - nothing worthwhile is acquired without much mucking about; mucking about is the engine of discovery.

There are collectors who love gear for its own sake and never use it – but photography is an activity large enough to contain contradictions. Each to their own. There are bad lenses for given applications: most enlarger lenses would be a surprising choice for sports or events photography. I wouldn't recommend a projector lens for architectural interiors - and even as I write that, I can think of several effective ways of doing just that . . .

Personally, I'm interested in images that tell stories, communicate the unfamiliar, provoke fresh perspectives, and confer immortality on eloquent moments – proper photography.

The 'rights and wrongs' of achieving those goals have nothing to do with brands, commonly-used combinations or received wisdom, and everything to do with finding a maximally distinct tone of voice appropriate to maximally distinct subjects.

If I was going to war over any issue, it would be to argue the primacy of such meaningful photography, that says something - relative to which, everything else is trivial.

But that too would be pointless, because plenty of folks just want to pick up a camera and capture images of their family on special occasions - and that is also special, and worthwhile. So I prefer not to fall out with anyone about photography, even if they're demonstrably wrong!


A hozzászólás legutóbb 16:9 által Pént. Jún. 10, 2022 12:21 pm-kor lett szerkesztve, összesen 2 alkalommal.


Reply

@simple.joy - thank you for posting those images: I'm head down shooting the same corner of my garden a thousand times to demonstrate differences in drawing styles and they've reminded me why I'm doing that. Is it time to unleash the Color-Solagons?

PS: What did that poor tablet ever do to you?


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 írta:
I'm currently really enjoying using an old Tessar 2.8/23 I ripped out of a broken Rollei A110 and remounted to use on my M4/3 cameras.









This is a good example of lousy adptation.
Apparently the lens was mounted so tilted that the slightly off-center image quality is completely compromised.
This is very evident in the texture of the wall. Compare center and off-center crops:

Center:



Off-center:



Incidentally, the photo is also an example of overly and poorly executed post processing, which is very evident in the horrible structure of the image noise.


Reply

Hey Gerald, thanks for showing everybody what an obnoxious piece of shit you really are.

Care to show us an example of a photo you have taken?

So we can critique it, in as obnoxious a manner as possible.

Almost certainly you won't, your ego is far too fragile to open yourself up to possible criticism, that's how all you trolling scumbags are - offensive in order to cover up your own deep-seated sense of inadequacy.


Reply

Whereas this shot today - Kodak Retinar S-AV 2000 135/2.8 - has the opposite vibe: lively, agitated bokeh and much shallower DOF. A lens that draws this much attention to itself is a completely different creative tool to the Perfex 75/3.5.



Reply

16:9 írta:
Whereas this shot today - Kodak Retinar S-AV 2000 135/2.8 - has the opposite vibe: lively, agitated bokeh and much shallower DOF. A lens that draws this much attention to itself is a completely different creative tool to the Perfex 75/3.5.



It seems that, unlike the first photo, the lens has been considerably stopped down, which would explain the difference between the respective bokehs.


Reply

I think you're misreading the image, but the captions explain: Perfex 75/3.5 and Retinar 135/2.8. Both shot wide open with circular apertures.

It's not (usually) possible to stop down a projector lens: they don't have diaphragms.

Differences in rendering style at different focal lengths and apertures goes without saying, but here, the difference is more about quality than quantity.


Reply

It's interesting how even the very samey chive pix have such different impact: stately and calm in the Perfex shot but with the Retinar, there's so much happening away from the focal plane, and it's all so distracting, the poor bee stationed dead centre is almost an afterthought: parsing the image, your attention dots all over the frame.

Is that wrong? It depends entirely on the creative intent.

simple.joy's images contrive backgrounds that are a playful counterpoint to the in-focus subjects. In the case of the bottle image, the bokeh leaps forward to participate with the foreground. To pull this off, the specular highlights have to have a certain shape and structure. Many of his images are bokeh-literate close-ups of chunky materials and ethereal settings, executed with grace. They also have a certain 'apochromatic' look. I think they're good examples of how to use a lens' tone of voice to say what's on your mind.

As is Ian's choice of a 'repressed contrast' lens to capture all that delicate early light and patterns in the high-key sky. The glow of doom around the horror-show petrol prices is a nice juxtaposition, too!

Most of the still photographers considered 'influential greats' limited themselves to a handful of lenses they knew. Their style, and the style of the lens, became one. Cartier-Bresson, obviously. Last week I was struck by it again reviewing the quiet consistency of Jane Bown's work: most of here portraits were shot with an Olympus 50mm prime at f2.8 - and if they weren't it wasn't by choice. Lenses of that period draw very particularly at f2.8: they are usually very sharp centre frame but still have soft Zones B and C, adding to the subject isolation. Wider, and they're too soft; stopped down - even at f4 - there's a lot more happening in the background. Jane was a 50/2.8 woman: expressing her self-effacing style with a subtle, graceful Olympus lens. Happy days.

Films are a different matter. DPs have to create a new world, with a distinct visual vocabulary, with every film. Their style has to serve the director's vision, which sometimes varies widely from scene to scene - often calling for radically different optics in the same movie. Here the question of 'looks' is (at it were) Paramount.


Reply

I like that bee image, I'm not usually a fan of busy bokeh, but I like that example.

It's obvious it isn't "considerably stopped down", hopefully by now it is also obvious to you that Gerald talks a lot of shite.

Is that Retinar 135 one of the ISCO made ones? I have a few Kodak & Meridian branded ISCOs, they are always interesting to play with.